Discussion : Logo Winner Annoucement

[CTPAHHuK]

Stop the flame please It Just MY personal Opinion. I can have it, or not ?
Make Love, NOT war

[benga]

I wouldn't care about colors, though. There are more companies using the same color scheme, just because of the color circle. So don't mind this. Microsoft has lots of copyrights, but surely not on green orange red & blue.

Congratulations!

I agree with Mondspeer, Microsoft doesn't have the rights to normal colors. Lets face it, what would open source become if our only choice are to be the opposite of that existing in the "Microsoft" world?

Bye the way, I didn't see the similar before and I work in a MS based world on daily basis.

Cheers
Bengt

[folders]

Congrats Alan

I think you did a fantastic job to bring in most of the elements what Joomla! is about  ;)

I'm really looking forward to seeing the new Joomla! grow and develop.

A well deserved Winner.

folders

[leolam]

Anyway I dont think we will be seeing him around.

talking about me? 
Where on earth if yes would you get that idea from?

[darkstar]

congrats to the winner my favorit was the last of the five  , but i like the idea behind the joomla1 logo... 

cu
darkstar

[bluesaze]

Where on earth if yes would you get that idea from?

soory you miss understood I meant the other guy .........
.......
just edited my original post.

[leolam]

Where on earth if yes would you get that idea from?

soory you miss understood I meant the other guy just edited my original post.

"think my emotional systems not yet calmed down" 

[bluesaze]

LOL      lets cut this crap out..... we should be discussing the logo

"think my emotional systems not yet calmed down"[/i] 

[leolam]

LOL      lets cut this crap out..... we should be discussing the logo

"think my emotional systems not yet calmed down"[/i] 

WHICH logo???  It seems we will have a new voting coming up on changes and that after are WE have chosen the first one ..........
bait, bait, bait, bait, bait  (any moment from now i will get burried by 95 kg kangeroo meat )

[urquharttownson]

Well everybody, off to bed I go...it's way past my bedtime. Got the modifications done to the logo and sent some color solutions for the logo to the development team. Don't worry some of the solutions use the same colors for all of those who like those colors as do I...just mixed the order up a bit so it doesn't follow the color wheel and doesn't match up with the MS Office logo. The other solutions were new color combinations. So as for the color, it's in the hands of the development team now. We'll have to wait and see what type of concerns they have about it and what direction they want to take. Once again...thanks to all who supported my logo design.

[sokratex]

my first impression when i saw this logo is that it looked like a microsoft one... microsoft office 2003 for windows...
see http://office.microsoft.com (upper left).

I had the same first impression, and I think it has more to do with choice of colors.

I really like the thought behind this logo and I am sure that it will grow on me. I like to congratulate the winner and all finalist for their achivements and the comunity for participating.

[dStorm]

@urquharttownson: Well done!  Definitely the most community-oriented logo of the bunch.

I have a feeling we haven't seen the last of the other logos either.  There are plenty of other Joomla-oriented websites, modules, components, etc... which could perhaps benefit from a logo... time will tell.

Cheers, Adam. (dStorm)

[MindTooth]

Wanna grat the winner

[tonezone]

I voted for the fish only because it was so different but I am very happy with Alan's design.

I think it's a great logo. And as far as the MS Office this is concerned, well I don't give two hoots that the colours are the same. Stick it to MS I say.

I'd say Alan choose those colours for the right reason and it's incidental that the colours resemble the MS logo. It's the meaning behind the logo that's important.

Well done mate.

[timide]

I hate it. It looks like Microsoftcrap. The fish was better. Well the CMS-name doesn't sound better either... but enough ranting.

[newart]

Congratulations to... the author and the community... I have to say that

[RobInk]

Mod note; please remain on-topic! Do not discuss personal opinions that would tunr into flaming. Mentioning a swastica should not be a proble, see here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swastika. It's even a Holy symbol. And to keep it on topic, do not reply to this either 

[interfaSys]

I too thought this logo was too close to Microsoft products. Those 4 coulors are known to be used by M$ in most of their products (Win, Office). But, hey, I should have said something earlier and now we have to live with it. Congrats to the winner!
Are the other logos Open Source? If not consider donating the bird to the OpenClipart library.

[leolam]

Mod note; please remain on-topic! Do not discuss personal opinions that would tunr into flaming. Mentioning a swastica should not be a proble, see here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swastika. It's even a Holy symbol. And to keep it on topic, do not reply to this either 

sorry Rob....be precise....I did not react initially (nor did i flame) on two (2) words and not on the swastika which word and value i personally understand very well. I reacted on the combined" fascist Swastika". I know the difference. That concludes the topic for me, tnx and mzl

leo

[whiteboxlabs]

great logo... very professional... (colors need a rework, just to avoid any appearance of impropriety.)

what impresses me is the amount of variety, yet how one item emerges and then gets refined over time to produce an incredible logo.

That process... even with detractors and disagreement is exactly what makes open source so great.  And exactly what the like os $iro and $icrosoft will never understand.

No one had to shove something through becasue it was their idea (ahem MS)...  Rather, transparently, with plenty of disagreement and dicussion, "everyone working together!"

No more 60's groovy flower power!

Excellent work.

[Vimes]

Well done Alan, glad to see my no. 1 got there.

[leolam]

Much is said about colors etc.....

Somebody who has a gathered a great deal of information on colors and pallettes is Tim Broeker and member of the Joomla core-team.  His blog and his gathered color pallette/links you will find here on his site mambofrog

very, very useful and loads of information right on the spot from Tim....Tnx mate!

leo

[Jelte]

I'm also very supprised that JBird did not win... found that the most professional.

But congratulation to Alan

Ps: LOL... in santapec avatar the bird has flying away

[leolam]

I'm also very supprised that JBird did not win... found that the most professional.

But congratulation to Alan

Ps: LOL... in santapec avatar the bird has flying away

haven't you seen him arriving at Miro yet?????? 






ps DO NOT TAKE THIS SERIOUS............. This is meant to be just a little joke!

If somebody offended i will immediately remove the pic!
leo

[marboo]

Congratulations Alan!
Didn't vote for it, but I will enjoy you logo next to the name!
Thank you!

[mambogfx]

http://forum.joomla.org/index.php/topic ... l#msg55411 what you think?

[marboo]

Ps: LOL... in santapec avatar the bird has flying away

I love the fact that Santapec shows a great sense of humour.
Just for this, if not only, congratulations!

[wspoint]

Congratulations! It was obvious this logo should win! 

[mediawizard]

Personally I don't mind the MS0/Joomla similarity. I didn't make the connection until it was presented to me and I work with MS Office all day every day.

Ditto

Ultimately I'm just happy we have a Logo and can move onto the next big thing!

Think the slogan topic is full already, something new for us to agree to disagree on

And about the colors, I don't think that's a big problem, we should just ask Microsoft to change their colors 

With the way the popularity of this is growing they just might

I did vote for this too, explains Joomla and provides simplicity through complexity, another important facet.

[bedlam]

I guess, like the Joomla! name ..... the logo will grow on me too 

so congrats to urquhart!  All the Top 5 are great designs