Sandbox

I was browsing and what I found is that the reviewes are turned into stupid comments.

So to avoid this, why don't you add one additional field, where developers can post a link to support forum or thread here at forum.joomla.org

It will be quite useful and will probably avoid this stupid comments.

agreed - there are some really stupic comments which cannot be called "Reviews" - some its even clear that the "reviewer" has not even tried the component

Hey guys,

Valid points. There are indeed some non-review comments among the Reviews and we have added a gentle reminder to explain what is expected from a review:

http://extensions.joomla.org/component/ ... 35/#action

Hopefully this will encourage less comments but more on real reviews. We will refer to these guidelines during approval from now onwards.