Sandbox

You get a mail once your review is approved.
You don't get anything if it is not.
Would it be possible to get alos a mail saying that a review was rejected?

I think I submited twice about this: http://extensions.joomla.org/component/ ... Itemid,35/ as no info, and no demo is accessible to anyone not registered on their site, and the description is a bit vague.
This is a commercial component, so at least there should be a way to see what it does without having to hand over your email..

Hi eyezberg,

Thanks for your suggestion of a "review not approved" email.

For a review to be approved it needs to qualify according to this:

What's in a review?
You are evaluating the extension based on your experience and usage. Share your thoughts about the extension, the pros and cons. If this is a good extension, why? What is the killer feature? If this is a bad extension, what are the shortcomings and if possible offer suggestions for improvement. Only reviews that meet these guidelines will be published.

Thanks, I am aware of that, but as you cannot use or "experience" this extension without signing up there (even the demo is registered access!), it is a bit weird to expect people to either buy this or give out their mail if they want a look..
Never mind, it's their business they're cutting short.

I have twicenow submitted a review of an extension stating that the description is incorrect and that it does not work as described. Its not been approved and I have recieved no notifiacation of any reason. (The author even says in his notes included with the extension that it does not work properly with firefox or gecko browsers yet the description says it does.)

eyezberg wrote:Thanks, I am aware of that, but as you cannot use or "experience" this extension without signing up there (even the demo is registered access!), it is a bit weird to expect people to either buy this or give out their mail if they want a look..
Never mind, it's their business they're cutting short.

@eyezberg: If the developer decide to show their info for registered users only, thats their choise. One can agree on that decision or not.

@brian: Glad that you double posted, cause there will then be one less to catch up on 
Sorry, but we haven´t evaluated your input yet, but sure soon will get to it.

Thanks for the reply

Glad to see that the review has now been "approved"