Page 1 of 1

reporting a review that is not relevant

Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2006 12:29 pm
by active_innovation
Hi

I have an extension that has been reviewed
by someone who has not even puchased the
application (commercial component), The claim
is that is a misleading listing although an approved
application by the moderators of the extension.
I have advised him to report the listing if he feels
it is against the guidelines of Joomla!

I feel therefore that he has not neither purchased
the application and that his review is just speculation
and critical of something that is not in the control
of application or the creator of the application then
this review should be removed.

The extension is call 'socioword' and can be found under
the my user name active_innovation.  If it is removed
I would also request that my response is also removed

thank you

Re: reporting a review that is not relevant

Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2006 1:40 pm
by ot2sen
Hi active_innovation,

The mentioned "review" did not apply to the rules of a review. Therefore it is now unpublished.
Reviews

A review is a serious examination of a person's experience with an extension which is presented on the Joomla! Extensions Directory. Praise, difficulties, or comparisons with other extensions are all valid parts of a review, including the reasons why.

Re: reporting a review that is not relevant

Posted: Wed Aug 16, 2006 2:59 pm
by active_innovation
I appreciate and applaud this decision.

rules and guidelines are there for a reason and without
them we open the door to malice, abuse and improper
dialogue.

Thank you ;)