illeo74 wrote:SineMacula wrote:illeo74 wrote:the hearth of joomla! is the community, so what do you think about this slogan: Joomla! Ccms (Community Content Management System). This community is great (logo competition is an example) so i think we have to exalt this project's side.
The heart behind the development of Joomla! is certainly the community, but an awful lot of sites built with Joomla/Mambo are not community sites at all - I myself have built 7 or 8 sites with it, and none of them is "community" based. I think that when considering a slogan, we need to think about how it's being used more than how it's being developed - since a lot of people who consider using it may not really care that much about the community behind it (at least not at first).
sorry, i don't explain very well how i have in my head (because my english is very down). my slogan don't explain kind of sites but the origin of project: if you choose joomla! for your site(s) you must know joomla! force (the community). i hope you understand me
I think I do understand you... I just happen to disagree
My personal opinion (and it is only an opinion) is that it makes more sense to have a slogan that presents prospective users (and the press) something about what it is, or how it's used, or how it makes their life easier/better/etc., or how they'll feel when using it.
A slogan should somehow play up the
benefits of Joomla and/or tell what it actually is either directly (e.g. "Joomla! Content management made easy") or semi-directly (e.g. "Joomla! Set your sites on it") or indirectly (e.g. "Joomla! It's just easier this way").
The fact that there is a strong, creative, wonderful community here supporting Joomla and the talented folks that develop it, and third party additions, is
very important to
us, but to people who are first coming to Joomla, looking for a CMS, it may not be important at all (especially if they're in the early stages of learning about the whole Open Source thing and the importance of these communities - as I was when I first discovered Mambo). For those that choose Joomla, many will discover the community, and its strength, diversity, and creativity after they start using it, if they don't do so during the exploration phase.
So, to summarize (sorry, I get long-winded near the end of my day... well, actually, time of day doesn't really matter
) -- it is my opinion that using the slogan to promote or express the fact that there is a strong community behind Joomla is not the best approach. But it's not up to me, so who knows?!?
I'll be happy to support whatever is decided!